Budget Oscilloscope Recommendation?

Steve Rieck

New Tinkerer
Mar 24, 2023
9
9
8
I want to see if the chips on my SE/30 reloaded board are functioning properly. I don't want to invest a lot at the moment. Just enough to know what might need to be replaced. Would something like this be adequate?

 
  • Like
Reactions: JDW

JDW

Administrator
Staff member
Founder
Sep 2, 2021
2,080
1,743
113
54
Japan
youtube.com
I'm one of those exceedingly (over-the-top?) meticulous people who spend a couple weeks reading every review and watching every YouTube video I can find on something before I buy it. Reading the technical documentation for a technical product is also a must. But I do that mostly when buying expensive things. The FNRSI product discussed in this thread sells for $31.44 after applying the 15% off coupon on Amazon. (Bear in mind that it used to be $18 according to a video I link below, which illustrates the rock-bottom category this product falls into.)

Note that OWON, HANTEK and FNIRSI are all entry-level, budget-friendly brands that don't necessary produce tools that please the discerning technician or electrical engineer. As such, they may or may not serve the needs of the user. This is why more research on the part of the buyer is necessary when purchasing expensive stuff, but again, the price of the item in this thread is super cheap. Nevertheless, I found a few reviews that may interest you...

This YouTube review indirectly gives the "pros" but gives no "cons" whatsoever:

There is some technical discussion on EEVBLOG, which is the go-to forum for deeper dives into electronics talk, as many EEs and serious electronics hobbyist are there:

But perhaps the best YouTube video review of that handheld scope though was done by Adrian here:

Adrian shows the tool's limitations by injecting a 1MHz signal into it, despite the tool being 200kHz rated. Adrian also shows alternative handheld scopes that cost less than $100, so those may be candidates for you too. But so long as you have low frequency testing requirements, that super cheap DSO152 may fit the bill.

Also note in Adrian's video that he uses some high quality measurement tools and has the same EEVBlog 121GW multimeter I use, and he also uses a DE5000 LCR meter which I also use. Excellent tools. But even those great tools require user understanding. If you watch his video further you'll see he finds a suspected bad axial cap on a C64 motherboard and uses his DE5000 (the best LCR handheld meter out there) and finds the axial cap doesn't look too bad, but when he swaps in a new cap, it cleans up the voltage. That illustrates why tools aren't magic. Tools sometimes don't help you get to the bottom of a problem. Is a given cap bad or not? Adrian felt the cap with his fingers and knew it too hot, then he swapped out the cap and that particular problem was resolved. So it's SMARTS + TOOLS that often lead you to a solution. SMARTS are acquired over time and almost always involve collaboration with experienced people in forums like this one.

BOTTOM LINE
Even though the current price on Amazon is higher than what Adrian paid ($18), the little meter is so cheap you should just buy it and test it. You know going in that it won't be the BEST tool for the job, but only by usage can you learn if it is GOOD ENOUGH. It might be good enough for you. Give it a try and let us know over time how it works for you!

FUTURE CHOICE?
I currently use a Rigol DHO804 hacked (for free, by me) to get 100MHz bandwidth. I paid $358.66-shipped at the end of 2023, and I must say that this particular scope is fabulous for me as an EE in my hobby usage. I even bring it to the office at times to do measurements there because it sometimes beats our more expensive scopes. Dave from EEVBlog did a detailed review of it here:

I am not suggesting you buy the Rigol though because, higher price aside, I think it would be too complex for you as a first-time scope buyer. That's why I think you should just buy that cheap FNRSI to get started. When you learn more about how scopes work and also when run up against the FNRSI's limitations, you can then start thinking about more expensive and feature-rich scopes. But keep in mind that some scopes cost thousands of dollars. That's why I was so impressed by the Rigol DSO804 because it doesn't make a lot of compromises and matches the performance of scopes costing a lot more. I say this only because there are real gems out there for good prices. Cheap doesn't necessarily mean useless.
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: Steve Rieck

Paolo B

Tinkerer
Nov 27, 2021
281
164
43
Switzerland
I have poor experience with those miniaturized scopes: they work, but they are indeed tricky to use in practice. Besides, you may probably need at least 2 channels.
So, on my end, not being a pro either, I eventually spent totally reasonable money (in the range of 120 USD) on a used, but still fully operational 500 MHz, 4 channels scope from Yokogawa.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Steve Rieck

Steve Rieck

New Tinkerer
Mar 24, 2023
9
9
8
I'm gonna go with the Zoyi ZT703S. Seems like significantly better quality and features for just a bit more money. Still very affordable.

 
Last edited: