Macintosh 128K, 512K, 512Ke, Plus broken speaker. Replacement advice needed.

OkSort7057

New Tinkerer
Apr 24, 2026
11
4
3
I have a 512K Macintosh that wouldn't do the bong when you start up. It would otherwise work fine. I checked the Control Panel volume and still didn't hear any sound. I also tried some games where I knew sound was present, but nothing. So in short - no sound at all. Then I plugged in headphones and I could hear all sounds through the headphones, including the startup bong.
I troubleshooted per Michael Pina's book: RF Shield short on J1 - no issue, battery B1 - no issue, Sockets J4 and J7 reflowed - no issue. Tested ohm from speaker - issue found: Open loop present.
I removed the speaker from the analogue board and found that it had an open coil. in fact when you move/shake around the speaker you could hear the lose part.
Now I'm looking for a replacement speaker on eBay:
Per Michael Pina's book, I can replace the speaker with a 4 Ohm, 8 Ohm, etc. as long as the Wattage is holding up. No less than 4 Ohm, 4W (or 8 Ohm 2W, 16 Ohm 1W, ...)
I found many speakers in that range, but very few of them have the 4 mounting holes I would rely on to attach the speaker back in the original spot.

If anyone has done such a replacement, it would be awesome to hear what speaker they used to replace it with that was a close to original fit.

I found these ones and per measurements, it should actually fit. Can anyone confirm?

57MM 8Ohm 8Ω 10W Full-range speaker Loudspeaker Neodymium Rubber edge
Screenshot 2026-06-05 at 10.44.44 AM.png
Screenshot 2026-06-05 at 10.44.49 AM.png
Screenshot 2026-06-05 at 10.44.55 AM.png

Screenshot 2026-06-05 at 10.44.26 AM.png

Per attached measurements, this should be an exact drop in replacement. it sticks out a bit more, but I verified there is no obstructions in the case, so the speaker mounting location can accommodate a deeper speaker like this. The Watt rating is a bit higher on this one, so it should sound better/louder, too.

For reference, this is the original speaker I took out from the Macintosh.

Screenshot 2026-06-05 at 10.49.38 AM.png
 

OkSort7057

New Tinkerer
Apr 24, 2026
11
4
3
I've also found these. They are not exactly a match in terms of dimensions, but would be able to be secured with 1 screw at least.

A Mini Speaker 8Ohm/2W.

Screenshot 2026-06-05 at 12.54.39 PM.png


A larger version, almost the size of the original speaker. I might need spacers, but mounting it would be tougher.
Screenshot 2026-06-05 at 12.55.11 PM.png


Is it safe to drill holes into the analog board to make it match? I'm trying to avoid anything to potentially damage the board, since it is 40 years old.

Another option would be to 3D print a bracket that could hold a speaker instead.